LEASE RENEWAL VS RELOCATION: SHOULD YOU STAY OR move?
A new lease can come with a better rent or a larger incentive, depending on the market and the premises. It also comes with fitout, removals and a make-good bill on the premises you are leaving. This puts both options on one line. Cash totals are indicative and undiscounted, and business disruption is not modelled.
Your numbers
Shared assumptions
Both options are costed over the same period.
Applied to rent and outgoings in both options.
Used to cost the make-good and any overlap rent.
Renewing where you are
Any work you fund to stay.
Relocating
Incentives on a new lease can be larger than on a renewal. Enter what the market is actually offering.
Net of any landlord contribution.
Removals, IT, communications, signage, downtime.
What you must spend to hand back the current premises.
Months paying both premises during fitout and transition.
Over a 5-year term
Renewing costs less
$0
Renewal build-up
Relocation build-up
Year by year
| Year | Renewal | Relocation | Difference | Cumulative difference | Ahead |
|---|
How this is calculated
Occupancy cost
Each option is area multiplied by net rent plus outgoings, escalating at the annual review in every year after the first. Renewal uses your current area; relocation uses the new area, so a change in floor plate is captured.
Incentives
Months of rent free are valued on the year one net rent of the relevant premises and deducted once. Incentives taken as a fitout contribution should be netted off the fitout cost you enter rather than added as rent free.
One-off costs
Renewal carries any upgrade you fund. Relocation carries fitout net of contribution, relocation costs, the make-good on the premises you are leaving, and overlap rent for the months you hold both. Make-good is charged only to relocation, on the basis that a renewal ordinarily defers it.
Break-even rent
The net rent per square metre on the new premises at which relocating costs the same as renewing, holding every other input constant. It is the number to take into a negotiation with the incoming landlord.
What is excluded
Business disruption, productivity effects, staff attrition, the time value of money, fitout depreciation and tax treatment are not modelled. Cash totals are undiscounted. A relocation with heavy upfront capital will look better on an undiscounted basis than it does on a discounted one.
Beyond the numbers
The calculator compares the cost of staying with the cost of moving. Several factors it cannot price can decide the outcome:
- Disruption to operations, customers and deliveries during a move
- Travel time and retention for staff
- Whether the current premises still suit the business, or are holding it back
- Time to find, negotiate and fit out new premises before the current lease ends
- Make-good obligations and any notice periods or option dates in the current lease
- Whether a credible alternative strengthens the negotiating position on renewal
A practical decision framework
Start with the business requirement, then test the options in this order. First, confirm the key dates in your current lease. Second, establish what the market would offer for comparable premises, including incentives. Third, compare the total cost of each option with this calculator and the occupancy cost comparison. Finally, weigh the factors above. Whether relocating brings a lower rent or a larger incentive depends on the market, the premises and the landlord, so treat the rent and incentive inputs as assumptions to test.
Tenant representation covers both paths: negotiating a lease renewal and finding and negotiating new premises. The renew or relocate guide walks through the decision step by step.
That knowledge is worth money in a renewal negotiation, and it is why a credible alternative changes the terms on offer. Represent runs both processes in parallel for occupiers.
Explore Tenant Representation →Only your email is required.
This calculator provides indicative modelling only and does not constitute financial, taxation, legal or property advice. Results depend entirely on the figures entered. Business disruption, productivity effects, fitout depreciation, tax treatment and the time value of money are excluded, and cash totals are undiscounted. Make-good obligations depend on the drafting of your lease and should be independently assessed. Represent Commercial. Real Estate Agent Licence 4949809.